Rewarding people without clocking their time: using Option Solving?

One of the big debates is how we reward or pay people based upon them having to clock-in and clock-out. Of course, the arguments for this issue are generally around the view that workers cannot always be trusted and that payrolls can be automated as much as possible. Conversely, others would say that it is a demeaning approach and signals that executives don’t trust them. Setting such issues aside for a moment, let’s consider some of our options to pay people without clocking in and out.
Firstly, of course, we need to define an appropriate question, which could look like this: “What is our best alternative for rewarding workplace people without clocking their time, considering…” Two points here: A) Note the question starts with “What,” which is designed to engage our intuition, since we use our intuition to answer questions of opinion. B) We need to pick the right considerations, as they will further provide our intuition with important points to sort out a particularly good option.
Many considerations could be listed here, but we can reasonably speculate on three that may well emerge: ‘Don’t wish to undermine morale,’ ‘We wish to keep things simple,’ and ‘We want to encourage people to go above and beyond.’ You can now view the final complete question under the Latest Example tab.
Now we need to frame things further with two “bookends,” the “yin and yang” extreme possibilities that come to mind from this question. The ones that particularly came to mind are: “Only reward people for a limited number of hours” and “Let people claim whatever hours they want.” It is clear neither of these is likely, but they are controversial options which help to stimulate our intuitive minds into creative activity.
Once in place, our intuitive minds are now challenged to develop a range of plausible options between these two extremes. The first one that could pop into our minds is: “Just pay people salaries along with deserved bonuses.” You can find the other four in our Latest Example.
At this point, you allow yourself or a team of executives some time out for “emotional distancing.” You can either put the option solving picture away for 5-10 minutes, while you or your decision group focus on something else, or decide to sleep on it. This allows time for our intuitive minds time to chew over the options and trade-offs, while dealing with other things or having a good night’s sleep.
You or your colleagues are now ready to make your best choice. A group of well-informed participants always facilitates the best overall decision. They should be given the opportunity to make confidential choices to mitigate against the ‘herd mentality’. We’ll leave you pick the one that you feel best meets the question.
If you have an example of your own, please share it with this blogger, through the COMMENTS area. Thanks Option Solving. (NOTE: Next posting in 2 weeks: “Using Option Solving to decide on ‘What is my best alternative to win my boss over?’” Let’s have your COMMENTS or go to peter@ileadershipsolutions.com to connect with the blogger.)

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: